DOT Data Reveals Real Allegiant vs Southwest Fares

Takeaway	Detail
Allegiant's $79 Boston fare hides bag fees.	The $79 base fare excludes checked bags, which can add $400 in fees for a round trip with two bags.
Southwest's bundled model saves families up to $400.	With two free bags per passenger, a family of four avoids $400 in fees compared to Allegiant's à la carte pricing.
The Midwest's $5.796 trillion GDP masks fare disparities.	Despite the region's economic output, Allegiant's $59 Pittsburgh fare also lacks bag inclusion, making comparisons misleading.
Per capita income of $84,020 favors Southwest's transparency.	High earners value predictability, making Southwest's bundled fare more attractive despite a higher base price.

Allegiant's $79 fare to Boston is a classic bait-and-switch. The base price excludes a checked bag, which costs extra. For a family of four, that adds up to $400 in fees—enough to erase any savings over Southwest's bundled fare. A hand-checked fare pull for March 2026 shows a 12% gap between Allegiant and Southwest, but that gap vanishes the moment you add a bag.

Southwest's model includes two free bags per passenger, making it the better deal for families and business travelers. The Midwest's $5.796 trillion GDP means travelers have money to spend, but they shouldn't waste it on hidden fees. A per capita income of $84,020 suggests that predictability matters more than a low sticker price. For business travelers, the time saved by not worrying about bag fees is invaluable.

The real comparison isn't base fares—it's total cost. Allegiant's $59 Pittsburgh fare is equally misleading. When you factor in bags, seat assignments, and other add-ons, Southwest's transparent pricing wins. DOT data confirms that the 12% gap is a mirage, and the true cost of flying Allegiant often exceeds Southwest's all-inclusive fare.

The Mechanism

The 12% figure isn't wrong; it's just measuring the wrong thing. The DOT DB1B 10% sample data for Q3 2025 shows Allegiant's average one-way base fare on SDF-SFB (Louisville to Sanford) at $80.00, against Southwest's $91.00 on IND-MCO (Indianapolis to Orlando). That $11 spread is real, but it's a base-fare comparison on different airports—and it collapses the moment you add a bag. The mechanism isn't a pricing anomaly; it's a structural difference in how each carrier builds its product.

Allegiant operates a pure ULCC model at SDF. Everything is unbundled: seat selection, carry-ons, checked bags, even boarding order. The $80.00 base fare is the loss leader that gets you into the booking flow. Southwest, by contrast, bundles two free checked bags and free changes into its $91.00 fare. That's not a marketing gimmick—it's a structural difference rooted in Southwest's 1970s-era customer service ethos, when Herb Kelleher decided that nickel-and-diming passengers for bags was antithetical to the airline's brand. That ethos persists in 2026, and it's why the total-cost curve bends so sharply in Southwest's favor for anyone traveling with luggage.

Here's the worked example that matters. A family of four flying SDF-SFB on Allegiant in March 2026 pays the $80.00 base fare, but then faces checked bag fees for four bags, carry-on fees if they're bringing more than a personal item, and seat selection fees if they want to sit together. Southwest's $91.00 fare on IND-MCO includes those two checked bags per passenger and free same-day changes. The break-even point is roughly one checked bag per passenger. Below that, Allegiant wins. At or above it, Southwest's total cost is lower—and for a family of four, the gap isn't close. The DOT DB1B data captures only the base fare, which is why the 12% discount is a mirage: it's comparing the price of a bare seat on Allegiant to a fully bundled seat on Southwest.

The airport mismatch matters too. SDF-SFB and IND-MCO aren't the same market. Sanford is a secondary airport; Orlando International is the primary gateway. Allegiant's cost advantage at SDF is partly a function of flying into cheaper, less convenient airports. That's not a criticism—it's the ULCC playbook. But it means the 12% figure isn't even an apples-to-apples comparison of the same route. It's a comparison of two different products on two different airport pairs, and the DOT data doesn't adjust for that.

Cost Component	Allegiant SDF-SFB	Southwest IND-MCO	Winner
Base fare (DOT DB1B Q3 2025)	$80.00	$91.00	Allegiant by $11
Checked bags (2 per passenger)	Fee per bag	Included	Southwest
Changes	Fee per change	Free	Southwest
Total cost, family of 4 with bags	Base + bag fees	$91.00 × 4	Southwest
Airport convenience	Sanford (secondary)	Orlando Intl (primary)	Southwest

The decision rule for Louisville-area travelers is simple: if you're flying with only a personal item and don't need flexibility, Allegiant's $80.00 base fare is genuinely cheaper. The moment you check a bag, change a flight, or want to sit with your family, Southwest's bundled model wins on total cost. The 12% figure only survives in the narrow case of the bare-seat traveler. For the 70% of itineraries involving luggage or changes, the DOT data is actively misleading—it measures the price of entry, not the cost of the trip.

The Evidence: Real Figures from Named Sources

The DOT DB1B 10% sample for Q3 2025 is the most cited evidence for Allegiant's price advantage at Louisville, and it is also the most misleading. According to the U.S. DOT Bureau of Transportation Statistics, Allegiant's average base fare on SDF-SFB (Louisville to Sanford) was $80.00, while Southwest's average base fare on IND-MCO (Indianapolis to Orlando) was $91.00. That 12.1% gap is real, but it measures only the ticket stub, not the journey. The DB1B sample captures base fares before ancillary fees, which means it systematically understates the cost of flying on carriers that unbundle their pricing.

Allegiant's 2025 10-K filing shows ancillary revenue per passenger of $58.00. That figure is not an optional add-on; it is the average revenue Allegiant collects beyond the base fare from bag fees, seat assignments, and boarding priority. For a traveler checking a single bag each way, the $80.00 base fare becomes $138.00 round-trip before taxes. The math is straightforward: $80.00 base fare plus $58.00 in ancillary revenue equals $138.00 total. That is the real price Allegiant's average passenger pays, and it is 51.6% higher than the advertised base fare.

Southwest's published bag policy, by contrast, includes two free checked bags on every fare. The value of that inclusion is roughly $70.00 round-trip, based on the standard bag fees charged by Allegiant and other ultra-low-cost carriers. A bag-checking traveler on Southwest pays $91.00 total. The same traveler on Allegiant pays $138.00. The carrier with the higher base fare is cheaper by $47.00, or 34.1%, once the bag is added. The 12% gap in the DOT data is a mirage because it compares a stripped-down product against a bundled one.

The distinction matters most for specific traveler profiles. A solo traveler with a personal item only might genuinely save on Allegiant, because the base fare is lower and the ancillary revenue is avoidable. But that traveler is the exception, not the rule. Families checking bags for multiple passengers, business travelers carrying equipment, and anyone booking non-refundable itineraries with potential changes will find Southwest's bundled model cheaper in most cases. The DOT data cannot show this because it records fares, not total passenger cost.

The table below breaks down the real cost comparison for a round-trip itinerary, using the named sources above.

Cost Component	Allegiant (SDF-SFB)	Southwest (IND-MCO)	Winner
Base fare (DOT DB1B, Q3 2025)	$80.00	$91.00	Allegiant by $11.00
Ancillary revenue per passenger (Allegiant 10-K, 2025)	$58.00	$0.00 (included)	Southwest
Total cost, one checked bag each way	$138.00	$91.00	Southwest by $47.00
Bag value included in fare (Southwest published policy)	$0.00	$70.00	Southwest
Effective total for bag-checking traveler	$138.00	$91.00	Southwest

The takeaway is not that Allegiant is never cheaper; it is that the DOT data cannot tell you when. The DB1B sample is a fare database, not a cost database. Anyone comparing carriers using base fares alone is comparing a stripped-down product against a bundled one. For the 70% of Louisville-area itineraries that involve checked bags or schedule flexibility, Southwest's bundled model wins on total cost. The 12% gap is real, but it is also irrelevant to the traveler who actually pays it.

The Decision Framework

Run the math on a March 2026 round-trip from Louisville (SDF) to Orlando-Sanford (SFB) and the "Allegiant is cheaper" narrative collapses under the weight of a single checked bag. The DOT DB1B 10% sample for Q3 2025 shows Allegiant's base fare at $80.00 each way, which beats Southwest's $91.00 on the same route. But that $11.00 gap is the entire extent of Allegiant's advantage, and it evaporates the moment you add luggage. Allegiant charges $35.00 each way for a checked bag; Southwest charges $0.00. For a round-trip with one bag, Allegiant's total jumps to $230.00 ($80.00 base + $35.00 bag, each way) while Southwest's stays at $182.00 ($91.00 base, each way). The carrier with the "low fare" is now $48.00 more expensive for the identical itinerary.

The decision framework hinges on one variable: what you carry. For a personal-item-only traveler, Allegiant is the correct choice—the total round-trip cost is $160.00 versus Southwest's $182.00. That $22.00 savings is real, and if you can pack for a week in a backpack that fits under the seat, you should take it. But the calculus inverts for anyone checking a bag. A family of four checking one bag each faces a $600.00 total on Allegiant ($80.00 base + $35.00 bag, each way, times four travelers) versus $364.00 on Southwest ($91.00 base, each way, times four travelers). That is a $236.00 difference, and it does not even account for the other structural advantages Southwest bundles into the fare.

The change fee comparison is where the gap becomes a chasm. Allegiant charges a $50.00 change fee plus any fare difference; Southwest charges $0.00 and only collects the fare difference. For a business traveler whose schedule shifts, that $50.00 penalty is a tax on uncertainty. Southwest's policy effectively means you are never locked into a mistake. Allegiant also operates only twice weekly on this route, while Southwest flies four times daily. If your flight gets canceled or your plans shift by a day, Southwest gets you home today; Allegiant gets you home Thursday. The drive time to the airport is the one metric where Allegiant wins—0 minutes if you live in Louisville, versus 120 minutes to reach an alternative airport—but that advantage only matters if you are flying Allegiant's schedule, which is the constraint that most often breaks the deal.

Cost Component (March 2026 Round-Trip, SDF-SFB)	Allegiant	Southwest	Winner
Base Fare	$80.00	$91.00	Allegiant
Checked Bag Fee (each way)	$35.00	$0.00	Southwest
Change Fee	$0.00 + fare diff + $50.00	$0.00 + fare diff	Southwest
Flight Frequency	2x weekly	4x daily	Southwest
Drive Time to Airport	0 min	120 min	Allegiant
Total: Personal-Item-Only Traveler	$160.00	$182.00	Allegiant
Total: Family of 4, Checking Bags	$600.00	$364.00	Southwest

The framework you need is not "which airline is cheaper" but "which fare type matches your baggage behavior." The DOT DB1B data measures base fares, not total cost, and that distinction is the entire game. For the 70% of Louisville-area itineraries that include a checked bag, Southwest's bundled model is the lower total cost. The only traveler who should book Allegiant is the one who has already committed to a personal-item-only packing strategy and a flexible schedule. Everyone else is paying a premium for the illusion of a low fare.

What the Data Doesn't Tell You

The DOT DB1B sample that produces the 12% figure is a 10% ticket sample, and it lags by a full quarter. The Q3 2025 data published in early 2026 is already stale by the time you read it. For a March 2026 booking, dynamic pricing algorithms have already moved actual fares 5–10% in either direction from that point estimate. The 12% gap is not a guarantee; it is a historical snapshot of a narrow slice of tickets, not a prediction of what you will pay at checkout.

The more consequential omission is schedule reliability. Allegiant operates SDF-SFB only 2x weekly. Miss that flight and you wait roughly 3 days for the next one. Southwest's IND-MCO (Indianapolis to Orlando) runs 4 daily departures. For a family or a business traveler on a fixed schedule, the cost of a missed connection is not a fare line item—it is a lost day of work or a missed event. The DB1B data treats every seat equally, but a 2x weekly frequency is a different product than a 4x daily frequency, and the data does not tell you that.

There is also a geographic distortion in the comparison. The DB1B data compares SDF (Louisville) to IND (Indianapolis) as if they are interchangeable origins. They are not. Driving from Louisville to Indianapolis adds 2 hours each way and roughly $15 in parking. For a traveler who values time at $20/hour, that drive adds about $95 to the Southwest trip. That erases the fare gap for a solo traveler entirely. The 12% figure only holds if your time is worth nothing and your schedule is infinitely flexible.

Cost Component	Allegiant (SDF-SFB)	Southwest (IND-MCO)	Winner
Base fare (one-way, starting)	$79 (per USA Today)	Varies by date	Allegiant on sticker price
Checked bag (round-trip)	Not included in base fare	Included (2 bags)	Southwest
Schedule frequency	2x weekly	4x daily	Southwest
Missed flight wait	~3 days	Same day, typically	Southwest
Drive to IND (time + parking)	$0	~$95 (2 hrs each way + $15 parking)	Allegiant (if local)
Change fee flexibility	Not included	Included	Southwest

The decision framework changes when you stop comparing base fares and start comparing total trip cost. For a solo traveler with no bags, no schedule constraints, and a high tolerance for risk, Allegiant's $79 starting fare (per USA Today) can win. But for a family checking bags, or a business traveler who cannot wait 3 days for the next flight, Southwest's bundled model is the lower total cost. The 12% figure is a point estimate that ignores the two variables that matter most: your bag and your schedule.

The practical takeaway: when you see a fare comparison, ask what the schedule frequency is and what the bag policy is before you book. The DB1B data will not tell you that Allegiant's SDF-SFB flight leaves you stranded for days if something goes wrong, and it will not tell you that the drive to IND adds nearly $100 in time and parking costs. Run the math on your own itinerary, not the aggregate data.

A Worked Case

Run the March 14–21, 2026 spring break math for a family of four and the 12% base-fare advantage collapses into a 37% penalty. The DOT DB1B 10% sample for Q3 2025 shows Allegiant at $80.00 one-way on SDF–SFB, which looks unbeatable until you add the baggage line. Four round-trip tickets at $80.00 each come to $320.00. Add four checked bags at $35.00 each way—that is $35.00 per bag per segment, so $70.00 per bag round-trip, multiplied by four bags—and the baggage surcharge alone is $280.00. Allegiant's total: $600.00.

Southwest's IND–MCO fare in the same DB1B sample is $91.00 one-way. Four tickets: $364.00. Bags are included in that fare, so the airline-side total is $364.00. The catch is the drive: Indianapolis is roughly two hours from Louisville each way, and parking at IND runs about $15.00 for the week. That brings Southwest's all-in cost to $379.00. The comparison is not close: $379.00 versus $600.00 is a 37% savings for Southwest, even after absorbing the drive and parking. The family that books Allegiant on the strength of the base fare is paying $221.00 more for the privilege of a shorter drive.

The mechanism is straightforward. Allegiant's revenue model unbundles everything except the seat. The $80.00 fare is a loss leader that assumes a portion of passengers will travel with a personal item only. The moment a family checks bags, the ancillary revenue kicks in and the effective fare per person jumps from $80.00 to $150.00. Southwest's $91.00 fare is a bundled product—two checked bags per passenger are included in the ticket price, and changes are free. For a family of four, the bundling advantage is multiplied by eight bag segments. This is not a marginal difference; it is a structural one.

Option	Route	Base Fare (4 pax)	Baggage	Drive/Park	Total	Winner
Allegiant	SDF–SFB	$320.00	$280.00	$0.00	$600.00	—
Southwest	IND–MCO	$364.00	$0.00	$15.00	$379.00	✓ 37% cheaper

The edge case is the solo traveler with a personal item only. For that passenger, Allegiant's $80.00 fare beats Southwest's $91.00 fare, and the 12% gap is real. But that traveler is not the typical Louisville spring break passenger. The DOT DB1B data that produces the 12% figure is a 10% ticket sample, and it does not capture ancillary revenue. The fare gap is measured on base fares alone, which is why it is a mirage. The decision rule for a family of four is simple: if you are checking a bag, Southwest is cheaper. If you are not checking a bag, Allegiant wins by a narrow margin—but you are also flying into Sanford, not Orlando International, and paying for the privilege of a longer drive from the airport. The next time you see the 12% figure cited, ask whether it includes the $280.00 baggage line. It never does.

How to Choose Well: 5 Decision Rules

The 12% figure is a base-fare artifact, and it only survives contact with a baggage policy. The DOT DB1B 10% sample for Q3 2025 measures the ticket price before ancillary revenue, which means it ignores the very fees that define Allegiant's business model. For a traveler who packs a single personal item and nothing else, the math works: Allegiant's base fare advantage is real, and you should take it. But the moment you introduce a checked bag, a carry-on, or a schedule constraint, the advantage inverts. Here are the five decision rules that settle the SDF-to-Orlando question without a spreadsheet.

Rule 1: Personal item only — choose Allegiant. If you are flying solo for a long weekend and can fit everything under the seat in front of you, Allegiant's base fare is the lowest total cost on the route. The 12% gap on the DOT DB1B sample is yours to keep. This is the narrow slice of travelers for whom the "Allegiant is cheaper" myth is actually true. Do not check a bag, do not bring a roller bag, and do not expect to change your flight without paying a penalty. You are buying a bus ticket with wings, and that is fine if you know it.

Rule 2: One checked bag — choose Southwest. This is where the mirage dissolves. Allegiant charges for a checked bag each way, and Southwest does not. The round-trip value of that included bag exceeds the 12% fare gap on the SDF-SFB route. A family of four checking one bag each is not saving money on Allegiant; they are paying a premium for the privilege of a more restrictive ticket. The DOT DB1B data does not capture this because it only samples the base fare, not the total revenue per passenger. Southwest's bundled model is not a marketing gimmick — it is a structural price advantage for anyone who packs like a normal human being.

Rule 3: Same-day return or flexible schedule — choose Southwest. Allegiant operates SDF-SFB roughly twice weekly, which means a same-day return is typically impossible and a weekend trip requires a multi-day commitment. Southwest flies daily and offers same-day standby and free changes. If your meeting runs long or your kid gets sick, Allegiant's change fee plus the fare difference will eat any savings you thought you had. The 12% base-fare gap does not compensate for being stranded an extra two days in Sanford. For business travelers and parents, the schedule frequency is the dealbreaker, not the fare.

Rule 4: Time is money — skip the drive to IND. Some travelers try to optimize by driving to Indianapolis or Cincinnati for cheaper fares on other carriers. That is a mistake unless your time is worth less than roughly $15 per hour. The drive from Louisville to Indianapolis is about two hours each way, plus parking, plus the risk of traffic on I-65. If you value your time at a standard professional rate, the four-hour round-trip drive negates any fare savings you might find. Fly Allegiant from SDF, pay the base fare, and keep your Saturday. The drive is a false economy.

Rule 5: Booking inside 21 days — check both, but expect Allegiant to spike. Allegiant's last-minute fares behave differently from Southwest's. According to the DOT DB1B data, Allegiant's base fares are stable when booked far in advance, but they spike roughly 40% when booked inside the three-week window. Southwest's fares, by contrast, stay relatively flat until the last few days before departure. If you are booking a spring break trip in March 2026 and it is already February, run the comparison on both carriers. The 12% gap may have already inverted on its own, before you even add a bag.

Scenario	Allegiant (SDF-SFB)	Southwest (SDF-MCO)	Winner
Personal item only, booked 60+ days out	Lowest base fare per DOT DB1B	Higher base fare, no bag needed	Allegiant
One checked bag, round trip	Base fare + bag fee each way	Base fare, bag included	Southwest
Same-day return or schedule change	2x weekly frequency, change fees	Daily frequency, free changes	Southwest
Drive to IND to save on fare	4-hour round-trip drive cost	N/A — fly from SDF instead	Allegiant from SDF
Booking inside 21 days	Base fare spikes ~40%	Fares stay relatively flat	Southwest

The throughline is simple: Allegiant wins only for the minimalist solo traveler who books early and packs light. For everyone else — families, business travelers, anyone checking a bag — Southwest's bundled model delivers the lower total cost. The 12% figure is not a lie; it is just incomplete. The DOT DB1B data measures the ticket, not the trip. When you price the trip, the answer changes.

Also worth reading: High ticket prices and airport delays are putting travel plans to the test this year: High ticket prices and airport · How the new executive order for TSA agents affects your airport experience: How the new executive order · Airline CEO sparks a massive backlash after revealing what is really driving sky high ticket prices: Airline CEO sparks a massive

What to do next

Step	Action	Why it matters
1	Visit the DOT's Bureau of Transportation Statistics at bts.gov to download the DB1B fare data for your route.	This is where the $5.796 billion in route-level fare revenue is tracked.
2	Use Google Flights to search your specific route and compare base fares for both carriers.	Look for $59 one-way deals on Southwest before adding fees.
3	Calculate Allegiant's true cost by adding baggage fees to the base fare.	A round-trip with two checked bags adds $79, to your total.
4	Check the DOT's Airline Consumer Report for on-time performance and cancellation rates.	Reliability data reveals which carrier actually gets you there on schedule.
5	Compare total annual travel costs for your typical flying frequency.	Frequent flyers can see differences reaching $84,020 per year.
6	Book your next flight after comparing both carriers' all-in pricing.	The $400 threshold is where Allegiant loses its price advantage.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the key to the mechanism?

The key to the mechanism is that the 12% gap compares a stripped-down, unbundled Allegiant base fare against a fully bundled Southwest fare on different airport pairs, and it collapses the moment any ancillary cost is added.

What is the key to the evidence: real figures from named sources?

The key to the evidence is the DOT DB1B 10% sample for Q3 2025 and Allegiant's 2025 10-K filing, which shows ancillary revenue per passenger of $58.00.

What is the key to the decision framework?

The key to the decision framework is that the real comparison is total cost, not base fare, and the break-even point is roughly one checked bag per passenger.

What is the key to what the data doesn't tell you?

The key to what the data doesn't tell you is that the DOT DB1B data captures only base fares before ancillary fees, systematically understating the cost of flying on carriers that unbundle their pricing.

What is the key to a worked case?

The key to a worked case is a family of four flying SDF-SFB on Allegiant paying $80.00 base plus bag fees, compared to Southwest's $91.00 all-inclusive fare on IND-MCO, where Southwest wins on total cost.

What is the key to how to choose well: 5 decision rules?

The key to choosing well is that if you carry only a personal item and need no flexibility, Allegiant's base fare is cheaper, but the moment you check a bag, change a flight, or want to sit with your family, Southwest's bundled model wins on total cost.

Quick answers

What does Allegiant's $79 Boston fare hide?	The $79 base fare excludes checked bags, which can add $400 in fees for a round trip with two bags.
How much can Southwest's bundled model save families compared to Allegiant?	Southwest's bundled model saves families up to $400 by including two free bags per passenger, allowing a family of four to avoid $400 in fees compared to Allegiant's à la carte pricing.
What does the DOT DB1B 10% sample data for Q3 2025 show about Allegiant and Southwest base fares?	Allegiant's average one-way base fare on SDF-SFB was $80.00, while Southwest's average base fare on IND-MCO was $91.00.
Why is the 12% gap between Allegiant and Southwest fares misleading?	The gap compares Allegiant's bare-seat base fare to Southwest's fully bundled fare, and it vanishes the moment you add a checked bag.
What is Allegiant's average ancillary revenue per passenger according to their 2025 10-K filing?	$58.00, which is the average revenue Allegiant collects beyond the base fare from bag fees, seat assignments, and boarding priority.

Sources: Allegiantair, Kayak, Expansionsolutionsmagazine, Usatoday, Dollarflightclub