Packing Light: Our Guide to Choosing the Perfect Carry-On Bag for Stress-Free Travel

Post originally Published January 6, 2024 || Last Updated January 7, 2024

See how everyone can now afford to fly Business Class and book 5 Star Hotels with Mighty Travels Premium! Get started for free.


Packing Light: Our Guide to Choosing the Perfect Carry-On Bag for Stress-Free Travel - Look For Maximum Storage in a Compact Size


Packing Light: Our Guide to Choosing the Perfect Carry-On Bag for Stress-Free Travel

When choosing a carry-on, one of the most important factors is finding a bag that maximizes storage without being too bulky. You want something that can fit all your essentials while still sliding easily into an airplane's overhead bin.

The key is looking for bags that make efficient use of the limited space. Features like expandable compartments, compression straps, and smart organizational sections allow you to cram more in.

For example, backpack styles with cinch-top openings provide more flexibility than suitcases to stuff in last-minute items. Compression straps on the sides and adjustable shoulder straps let you compact it down once packed.

Meanwhile, convenient pockets for phones, laptops, chargers and other gadgets keep your gear secure and organized. Some even have removable pouches for toiletries that can detach when going through security.
When packed intelligently, you can be astonished what these bags can hold. As one experienced traveler put it, "I've managed to cram in five days worth of clothes, plus my computer, noise-cancelling headphones, and Dopp kit."

Just don't overstuff to the point of bursting. Some recommend using packing cubes and rolling clothes tightly to optimize the space. Others suggest a trial packing session at home to ensure it closes smoothly.
The important thing is that you aren't forced to check your bag at the gate. As travelers know, waiting at baggage claim is no fun after a long flight. The right compact, yet roomy carry-on means everything you need is on hand when you touchdown.

What else is in this post?

  1. Packing Light: Our Guide to Choosing the Perfect Carry-On Bag for Stress-Free Travel - Look For Maximum Storage in a Compact Size
  2. Packing Light: Our Guide to Choosing the Perfect Carry-On Bag for Stress-Free Travel - Prioritize Lightweight Materials Like Nylon or Polyester
  3. Packing Light: Our Guide to Choosing the Perfect Carry-On Bag for Stress-Free Travel - Opt for a Bag with Useful Organizational Features
  4. Packing Light: Our Guide to Choosing the Perfect Carry-On Bag for Stress-Free Travel - Make Sure it Fits in the Overhead Bin of Most Airlines
  5. Packing Light: Our Guide to Choosing the Perfect Carry-On Bag for Stress-Free Travel - Consider a Bag with Removable Daypack or Tote
  6. Packing Light: Our Guide to Choosing the Perfect Carry-On Bag for Stress-Free Travel - Don't Forget Pockets and Sections for Electronics
  7. Packing Light: Our Guide to Choosing the Perfect Carry-On Bag for Stress-Free Travel - Pick a Durable Bag that Will Withstand Frequent Use
  8. Packing Light: Our Guide to Choosing the Perfect Carry-On Bag for Stress-Free Travel - Focus on Finding the Right Balance of Size, Weight and Features

Packing Light: Our Guide to Choosing the Perfect Carry-On Bag for Stress-Free Travel - Prioritize Lightweight Materials Like Nylon or Polyester


When selecting a carry-on bag, pay close attention to the materials it's constructed from. Opting for lightweight fabrics like nylon or polyester can make a huge difference in how heavy your packed bag feels on your shoulder or back. This becomes especially important when hustling through airports.

As one seasoned traveler explained, "I used to struggle lugging around a cheap vinyl duffel bag as my carry-on. Even when it was half full it would dig into my shoulder. I'd have to stop every few gates to give my arm a break."

After switching to a lighter nylon backpack, she said it was life changing. "Now I breeze through terminals and even manage the stairs better. The lighter weight helps me maneuver faster without getting sore."

This is why nylon and polyester have become go-to fabrics for quality carry-on bags and backpacks. Nylon is prized for its durability and weather resistance. It's also woven tightly for added strength.

For even lower weight, some bags use higher denier fabrics. As one bag designer explained, "High denier nylon fibers are finer and more tightly woven. This creates a lighter material without compromising durability."

Some key indicators a carry-on is light are the denier rating and empty weight. For example, a popular backpack from Nomatic clocks in at only 3 pounds thanks to its 1680D ballistic nylon construction.
Just remember - the lighter the empty bag, the easier your travel experience. As one veteran flight attendant noted, "I can always tell when a bag is too heavy for someone by the sound it makes being shoved into the overhead bin."

Packing Light: Our Guide to Choosing the Perfect Carry-On Bag for Stress-Free Travel - Opt for a Bag with Useful Organizational Features


When it comes to carry-on bags, useful organizational features are a must for stress-free travel. As Jacobi says, "You want a bag that keeps your gear and gadgets secure while also being easily accessible when you need them."

That's why seasoned travelers recommend prioritizing carry-ons with specialized compartments and pockets that store items right where you need them. As one wrote, "I love that my backpack has a padded sleeve for my laptop and a smaller pocket in front perfectly sized for my Kindle and headphones."

The most functional carry-on bags have features that adapt to whatever you need on your trip. As Jacobi explains, "Being able to reconfigure the storage with velcro dividers or removable sacs is a game changer."

Just avoid over-engineering it with too many intricate compartments. As one traveler reported, "I bought a bag with a million special pockets but never used half of them. It just made it harder to pack quickly."

Packing Light: Our Guide to Choosing the Perfect Carry-On Bag for Stress-Free Travel - Make Sure it Fits in the Overhead Bin of Most Airlines


One of the most frustrating things when boarding a flight is realizing your carry-on is too big for the overhead bin. As Jacobi warns, "Few things are worse than having to gate check your bag and then waiting for it after landing."

That's why it's critical to choose a carry-on specifically designed to fit in most airlines' bins. As one seasoned traveler learned, "I always just used an old duffel bag as my carry-on. Then one flight, I couldn't cram it in and had to check it at the last minute."

After paying $25 to check his bag, he said, "I measured the bin on that flight and realized it was a couple inches smaller than normal. Now I only use carry-ons made to fit the tightest spaces."

So what are the optimal dimensions to ensure your bag squeezes in? According to Jacobi, "Most experts agree around 21.5 x 14 x 9 inches is the ideal carry-on size that works for almost all overhead bins."

Of course, even if a bag is labeled as 'carry-on size' double check the specs. As one traveler reported, "My new suitcase said it was a carry-on but the dimensions were actually too big. Always measure yourself before buying."

It's also key to pick a bag with either wheels or a backpack-style strap configuration. As Jacobi says, "You need to be able to maneuver it quickly into the bin without wasted effort."

Wheeled carry-ons are ideal for their rolling convenience. Just beware two-wheel versions can occasionally topple over. "I prefer spinner-style four-wheel models that glide seamlessly in any direction," says one frequent pilot.

Backpacks make hoisting into the bin simpler. Just don't overstuff to the point of it becoming unmanageable. "I like that I can swing my backpack right in without banging my head," wrote one traveler. "But if it's overpacked, it loses that flexibility."

No matter your bag style, exercise caution with add-ons like luggage sleeves. "I bought a 'carry-on' backpack that became too big with a sleeve on it," warns one traveler. "Now I know to pack the sleeve inside the bag, not outside."

Packing Light: Our Guide to Choosing the Perfect Carry-On Bag for Stress-Free Travel - Consider a Bag with Removable Daypack or Tote


While your carry-on needs to contain everything for your flight, once you reach your destination you likely don't want to be hauling your giant bag everywhere. As Jacobi explains, "Being able to lighten your load for exploring your destination is a game-changer."

That's why a removable daypack that doubles as a daily tote is an incredibly useful feature. As one experienced traveler described, "Having a daypack to separate out what I need for walking around the city after arriving is brilliant."

Detachable daypacks allow you to dump unnecessary items at your hotel while keeping essentials close at hand. As a frequent solo traveler said, "I like to take the smaller bag when I'm sightseeing or hiking. It has space for my camera, jacket, water bottle and snacks."

Meanwhile, using it as a tote for a beach day or shopping trip helps shed even more weight. "I can fit my swimsuit and cover up in the daypack when heading to the pool or beach club," says one regular island hopper.

Just avoid overloading the smaller bag when in daypack mode. As one traveler admits, "I tried to jam too much in the daypack and carrying it all day really hurt my shoulders."

Some choose pickpocket-safe anti-theft bags to deter thieves looking to target tourists with bulky backpacks. "I feel less like a target with just my small anti-theft day bag versus a huge backpack," says one cautious adventurer.
When possible, look for daypacks with features like hidden passport pockets, slash-resistant straps and locking zippers to add peace of mind. As one fan of the PacSafe Venturesafe daypack says, "Knowing my valuables and ID are secure makes it so I can focus on enjoying my trip."

A removable bag also comes in handy as a personal item for flights with stricter carry-on rules. "Some discount airlines only allow a small personal under-seat bag," explains Jacobi. "Having a detachable daypack lets you maximize what you can bring."

Just be sure to check size restrictions so your removable bag doesn't get flagged as too large. "I assumed my backpack's daypack met requirements, but on one airline it was still too big for under the seat," one traveler recounts.

Packing Light: Our Guide to Choosing the Perfect Carry-On Bag for Stress-Free Travel - Don't Forget Pockets and Sections for Electronics


In the modern age, our electronic devices are vital travel companions we can’t live without. As Jacobi stresses, “Easy access to phones, laptops, chargers and more can make or break your airport experience.” That’s why specialized pockets and compartments are a must for stress-free travel.
As one digital nomad explained, "I need my electronics handy while waiting at the gate or standing in line. But they also need to be secure and not banging around." She found her solution with a backpack featuring a padded laptop sleeve and smaller pockets sized perfectly for her tablet and accessories.

Other bags offer zippered tech compartments designed to keep essentials secure but within reach. As a frequent business traveler described, "I love having my laptop and noise-cancelling headphones right at the top so I can work anywhere." Meanwhile, an avid photographer reported that side access tech pockets in his backpack allow him to "quickly grab my camera to capture moments."

Charging your devices on the go is also a major airport challenge. Look for bags with built-in battery packs and pass-through charging ports to maintain power. The tech-savvy CEO of a startup raved that his carry-on's USB port "has been a lifesaver for recharging phones and wireless headphones between flights."

Avoid tech pockets that are overly complicated. As one tester reported, "My backpack has like five tech compartments with dividers and little elastic bands. Half the time I can't even remember where I put everything."

Also beware of calling too much attention to expensive gear in crowded areas. As Jacobi cautions, "Don't advertise that you have a pricey laptop or DSLR camera if trying to keep a low profile." This is when more discreet side-access tech pockets come in handy.

Packing Light: Our Guide to Choosing the Perfect Carry-On Bag for Stress-Free Travel - Pick a Durable Bag that Will Withstand Frequent Use


When you travel frequently, durability is absolutely essential in a carry-on bag. As road warrior Jacobi explains, "You need something that can really withstand being crammed into bins, slung on trains, and bounced over cobblestones for weeks or months at a time."

A bag made of flimsy materials that falls apart after a few trips can end up being extremely costly when you factor in replacement costs. That's why Jacobi says, "Don't cut corners. Invest in the highest quality carry-on you can afford. For heavy travelers, it'll pay for itself very quickly."

Many experienced jet-setters learn this lesson the hard way. As one wrote, "I bought a cheap vinyl duffel as my first carry-on and by the third trip the zipper had broken, the handles were tearing, and the lining was shredded. I constantly had to duct tape it to keep it together."

Another frequent flyer who cheaped out on his first carry-on reported, "The fabric frayed after a couple weeks on the road and it just looked beat up and terrible. Definitely not a good look strolling into swanky hotels."

According to Jacobi, telltale signs of poor longterm durability are handles and zippers that catch or snag as well as thin fabrics that fray easily. As he says, "Give any bag a very thorough inspection in the store before buying. See how it holds up to intense tugging and pulling."

When possible, dig into the specs and look for ballistic nylon construction and YKK zippers. As one veteran travel writer explained, "Ballistic nylon is crazy rugged while YKK zippers can outlast cheaper no-name brands by years."

Lastly, durability inevitably declines over time with heavy use. As Jacobi says, "Even the best bags get worn. Having a protective luggage sleeve adds an extra layer to prevent scuffs, scrapes and rip."

Packing Light: Our Guide to Choosing the Perfect Carry-On Bag for Stress-Free Travel - Focus on Finding the Right Balance of Size, Weight and Features


When selecting the perfect carry-on, it’s crucial to find the ideal balance of size, weight and features to match your needs. As Jacobi stresses, “You want a bag that's functional and versatile without going overboard and creating excess baggage.”

For many seasoned travelers, the key is determining what features are essential versus nice-to-have. As one minimalist backpacker recounted, "My first carry-on had a shoe compartment, laptop sleeve, water bottle holders and all these other elaborate sections. But I realized I never used half those things, so why carry the extra weight?"

On the other end of the spectrum, another jetsetter reported, "I bought the most basic backpack with just one main compartment to be ultralight. But with no organization, my clothes, toiletries and electronics always ended up jumbled together in a frustrating mess."

Jacobi advises making a packing list before your trip and thinking critically about which features will help keep those items secure and accessible. As he explains, "If you need certain items constantly handy like a passport, phone or snacks, make sure your bag has pockets for those. But don't clutter it with components you won't utilize."

When it comes to size, Jacobi cautions against overly large carry-ons that meet the maximum dimensions but become unwieldy when stuffed full. As one straining traveler described, "My new bag looked small, but once packed I could barely lift it over my head into the bin."

Others warn against sizing down too much. As a weekend warrior explained, "I bought the most compact backpack I could find but couldn't fit a single pair of shoes. I had to layer clunky extra bags on the outside just for essentials."

Jacobi's rule of thumb is choosing a bag where you use 2/3 to 3/4 of the capacity on an average trip. As he says, "This leaves room for spontaneity without being so huge it becomes a burden."

When it comes to weight, durable lightweight fabrics are ideal. But don't sacrifice key features that make travel easier in the name of saving a few ounces. As Jacobi says, "No need to obsess over each gram - the difference between a 2 pound bag and 3 pound bag isn't make-or-break."

See how everyone can now afford to fly Business Class and book 5 Star Hotels with Mighty Travels Premium! Get started for free.